The Howard Staunton Memorial Chess tournaments were staged for several years at Simpsons-in-the-Strand, the traditional home of British Chess. At one of these august events, Professor Michael Crawford, in his persona as Director of The Institute for Brain Chemistry and Human Nutrition, based at Londons Imperial College, delivered an opening speech, and one deliberately aimed at the players in the event.His point was that the consumption of marine based nutrition was beneficial for the brain.
Listening in the audience was the Grandmaster Nigel Short, Britains only challenger for the World Chess Title in the 20th century. Emulating Sherlock Holmes and Dr. Watson after the successful denouement of the short story,The Dying Detective, Nigel went to Simpsons dining room for something nutritious a giant Dover sole. Nigel persevered with his piscatorial, brain-enhancing diet throughout the competition and duly turned in a superb performance.
Professor Crawford does not just confine his dietary advice to fish and related aquatic delicacies. He is also a keen apiarist and advocate for the health benefits of honey, in particular raw honey, that retains the vital pollen, which the EU would so like to remove. In his guise as a beekeeper, Professor Crawford has now challenged me to write a column forTheArticle, linking bees and chess.
The solution to this conundrum is, in fact, relatively simple, in that both bees and chess have famously been invoked as models for exemplary social structures. There is a vase by Exekias in The Vatican Museum, as indeed another in The British Museum, which depicts the heroic warriors Ajax and Achilles absorbed in a board game, one of the hallmarks of a civilised society, during the siege of Troy.
The game involved was almost certainly not chess, but Achilles himself definitely figures in Homers use of bees to delineate the harmonious running of society. In his bee similes, Homer underscores the reciprocal dependencyof the collective, the individual, and the household, extolling unity within diversity. Homer describes the Greeks gathering for a council of war, writing in hisIliadcirca 700 BC, and , in this instance, they resemble a cloud of bees:
as when offrequentbeesSwarms rise outof a hollow rock, repairing the degreesOf their egression endlessly,with ever rising newFrom forth their sweet nest;as their store, still as it faded, grew,And never would cease sending forthher clusters to the spring,They still crowd out so(HomersIliad, Book II, lines 87-93. Translated by George Chapman, first published in 1598).
This simile emphasises the unity of the individuals who make up the Greek army, illustrating the ideal dynamic, in which neither the interests of the individual, nor those of the collective, take excessive precedence. According to Homer, a fully functioning society will, therefore, maintain a balance between unity and diversity.
Yet they,as yellow wasps, or bees(that having made their nestThe gasping cranny of a hill)when for a hunters feastHunters come hot and hungry in,and dig for honeycombs,Then fly upon them, strike and sting,and from their hollow homesWill not be beaten, but defendtheir labours fruit, and brood;No more will these be from their port,but either lose their blood(Iliad, Book XII, lines 167-170).
Thus,each Greek warrior is actually promoting his own personal interests, whenever he defends the collective. It is at the tipping point where individuality exceeds its bounds and proper discipline is abandoned, that disaster strikes, as when Achilles sulks in his tent and his soul mate, Patroclus, is inadvertently slain, by the Trojan hero, Hector.
Shakespeare encapsulates this problem in his tragedyTroilus and Cressida, when the wily Odysseus (identified by his Latin name Ulysses in the play) explains that order, or degree, has broken down: Take but degree away, untune that string, and hark, what discord follows!
Bee similes also figure prominently in VirgilsAeneid, appearing first in Book I, then in Book VI, and finally in Book XII. Their studious arrangement suggests that, like Homer, Virgil regarded bees as significant, in order to fully comprehend hisentire magnum opus. Indeed, Virgils other works support this inference, because they prove that Virgil considered bees toexemplify a well-organised, homogenous, and dutifully obedient society.
In his poemGeorgics(Book IV) Virgil discusses bees and their habits at length, using bees as a paradigm for his vision of the perfect society: a hardworking, patriotic, thrifty, disciplined community, all striving towards a single, noble end. Each of the four references to bees in theAeneidprovides an insight into this model community, especially emphasising the collective, renascence, and the future foundation of Rome itself.
In Virgils time (writing in the late 1st century BC), it was still believed, following Aristotles lead, that the hive was ruled by a king bee (rather than a queen) which makes the deployment of the bee simile/metaphor of precise relevance in the transition period between the Roman Republic and the Roman Empire. In fact, it was not until 1609, with Charles ButlersThe Feminine Monarchy,that the Queen was correctly identified, not so much as a leader, more as afons et origoof the hive.
Such is their toil, and such their busy pains,As exercise the bees in flowry plains,When winter past, and summer scarce begun,Invites them forth to labor in the sun;Some lead their youth abroad, while some condenseTheir liquid store, and some in cells dispense;Some at the gate stand ready to receiveThe golden burthen, and their friends relieve;All with united force, combine to driveThe lazy drones from the laborious hive:With envy stung, they view each others deeds;The fragrant work with diligence proceeds.(VirgilsAeneid, Book I, lines 430-436.Translated by John Dryden and first published in 1697.)
Virgils bees are not a clustering swarm, like Homers, but a homogenous mass, divided only by their varying tasks, which they perform faithfully and mechanically. Such a devoted and focused society, in Virgils mind, represents the ideal human template forcivilisation. The poet illustrates the importance of the collective, but dismisses individuality altogether, a shift that distinguishes him from Homer. It is easy to see the direction in which the poet is leading us.
In sharp contradistinction to the poet Ovid, who was banished by the Emperor Augustus far from Rome to Tomi on the Black Sea, Virgil is composing state-sanctioned, if subtly disguised, propaganda, where one emperor and one unified compliant imperium are the order of the day.In actual bee society, this is stretching the metaphor, but as a refined political message within human society, it is highly persuasive. It is a feat of legerdemain, not lost on contemporary environmental advocates, to imply that the path to paradise for humans lies in a direction imposed by nature itself. As Alexander Pope put it in hisAn Essay on Man:
All nature is but art, Unknown to thee;All chance, direction which thou canst not see.
Virgil emphasises the paramount importance of society and the need for people to have their appointed place in it, implying that the collective must take precedence over the individual. Roman society was, indeed,highly stratified, and, again, Shakespeare points the way in the opening lines ofJuliusCaesar:
Hence! Home, you idle creatures, get you home. Is this a holiday? What! Know you not. Being mechanical, you ought not walk. Upon a labouring day, without the sign of your profession. Speak, what trade art thou?
Liberal arts or professions in Rome were those practised by free men and included rhetoric, law, politics, poetry, medicine and architecture. Opposed to these were those considered sordid, such as portitor (the boatman or carrier), fenerator (the usurer), while lowest of the low were craftsmen who worked with fire, such as smiths and potters, known as banausic in Greek and mechanical in Latin.
Virgil understands a beehive to be an illustration of human civilisation. Though the individual will pass away, the legacy of the community will endure. Over and over again, the hive is reborn as a new generation of insects rises to take the place of the old one, defying and surviving various crises, such as
Thus, when the swain, within a hollow rock,Invades the bees with suffocating smoke,They run around, or labor on their wings,Disusd to flight, and shoot their sleepy stings;To shun the bitter fumes in vain they try;Black vapors, issuing from the vent, involve the sky.(Aeneid, Book XII, lines 587-592).
This simile introduces a significant, final aspect of Virgils ideal society: the shepherd, or leader of the people.
According to Virgil, the ideal society must have a ruler. Again,GeorgicsBook IV provides an explanation, using the bees devotion to the ruler, which the Romans, as we have seen, interpreted as a king, although due to more modern science we now know to be a queen. The bees labour intensively and selflessly, because of the ruler; but when that ruler eventually expires, the hive degeneratesand the bees annihilate their own work.Likewise, a rulers wise guidance unifies the Apian way and thus preserves the peoples purpose.
It is impossible, once again, to avoid inferring a reference here to the rise of Augustus. In particular, hissoi distant necessaryslaughters of the opposition on his way to the top, such as the proscriptions of the second triumvirate, and the cauterisation of the wounds caused by fanatic republicans, such as Brutus and Cassius.In Virgils vision of the perfect Roman society, such harsh measures are justified, if order and universal peace, the Pax Augusta and the closing of the doors of the temple of Janus, are to be the beneficial outcome.
Now we come to the chess element of the equation, proving unequivocally that chess, in common with bees, has been adapted as a social model, one singularly popular in the late Middle Ages. At that time, chess was already recognised as one of the seven liberal arts, supposedly promulgated by Aristotle, no less, the sage described by Dante as il maestro di Collor che sanno (the Master of the men who know). These were meant to be the common attributes of knights and their ladies, embracing,inter alia, equestrianism, toxology, pugilism andde arte venandi cum avibus(the art of hunting with birds, or in other words falconry).
Around 1300, the northern Italian Dominican Friar, Jacobus de Cessolis published his moralising book about chess,Liber de Moribus hominum et officiis nobilium super ludo scacchorum. Packed with entertaining stories and material ripe for sermons, this book proved inordinately popular, even appearing as the first book ever published in English, in England, by Caxton in the late 1470s,The Game and Playe of the Chesse.
One turns to Cessolis in vain for instruction on how to win at chess, instead the descriptions of the pieces and pawns stratify and reinforce the prevailing social order. Although a hierarchical social model is by no means inherent in the game of chessper se, it is no surprise that such a self-perpetuating template was so popular with kings, dukes and other members of the ruling nobility, whose libraries often contained multiple copies.
The ranks of society, according to the Cessolis template, began with the King and Queen, at the apex,followed by the Alphins, aka bishops or judges, then knights and rooks, or royal messengers, followed by the common people, in other words, the pawns. Indeed, the eight pawns on each side were actually credited separately with their trades, much as in the antique Roman classification mentioned both by Shakespeare and the Lewis & Short Latin dictionary. The trades included labourers, tillers of the earth, drapers and makers of cloth, merchants, money changers, physicians, taverners and the banausic or mechanical trades of smiths and other workers in iron and metal.
The word Alphins (bishops) requires some explanation. The concept still survives in Spanish (Alfil) and Italian (Alfiere) where the L/F sound is more important than the meaning, signifying a reference to the word elephant, the root of which is Aleph Hind, or Indian Ox. Since most Western Europeans would never have seen such a pachyderm, it was the phonetic representation, rather than the meaning, which travelled with the expansion of chess. Traces of Alphin can also be found in other languages, where the word for a chess bishop embracesLe Fou, the jester in French,Loperin Dutch,Luferin German, both meaning runner andLovac(hunter) in Serbo-Croatian. As one journeys further East, however, the modern mammoth reclaims its own, as in the Russian for Bishop,Slonwhichtranslates as the elephant.
The book of Cessolis drew on and strengthened the late mediaeval mind-set that chess was a symbolic representation of society and imparted to that notion much greater force and precision. At one point it was, though still a distant rival, second only to The Bible in terms of popularity, and thus merits its place alongside the bee metaphors of Homer and Virgil, as a genuine attempt to describe an ideal social structure of civilisations which have long since fallen into desuetude.
Fascinating, as it is, to excavate mediaeval views about chess, the modern game still continues apaceand twochess news items of note occurred this past week. The first was the87th birthday ofDr. Jonathan Penrose. He won The British Chess Championship a record ten times and was subsequently awarded the Grandmaster title Emeritus.His doctorate is in Psychology. His brothers areOliver Penrose, as well as prominent author and physicist Professor Sir Roger Penrose, who was honoured with the 2020 Nobel Prize in Physics, for his discovery that black holes are a robust confirmation of Einsteins general theory of relativity.
The second momentous item of note was the first loss by World Champion Magnus Carlsen in classical chess for two years, two months and ten days. Carlsen suffered this rare setback against Jan-Krzyztof Duda last Saturday in Stavanger, Norway, where the first over the board elite event for many months has been taking place, in spite of Covid 19 restrictions. Here is a link to the game, with commentary.Carlsens 125 game unbeaten streak is a World Record and in next weeks article I shall be looking at world records, including Carlsens unbeaten run in chess, as well as two in other sports, which occurred recently, in both tennis and Formula 1.
Continue reading here:
- Chess Corner: Sitting on the 7th rank - Muskogee Daily Phoenix - June 11th, 2021
- Joe Burrow is so competitive he's trash talking teammates about...chess - Bengals Wire - June 11th, 2021
- PhosAgro Renews Strategic Partnership Agreements with FIDE and the Russian Chess Federation - PRNewswire - June 11th, 2021
- Long Island brothers create website to bring chess lovers together virtually - News 12 Bronx - June 11th, 2021
- Nuclear powers must stop playing nuclear chess and atomic roulette - The Mail & Guardian - Mail and Guardian - June 11th, 2021
- Joe Burrow has Been Talking Crap About Chess to a Key Offensive Target - Sportscasting - June 11th, 2021
- Aamir Khan will face the chess with chess champion Viswanathan Anand - asume tech - June 11th, 2021
- 2021 Scholar-Chessplayer Award Winners Announced | US Chess.org - uschess.org - uschess.org - June 11th, 2021
- 2021 Executive Board Election Ballot Mailing | US Chess.org - uschess.org - June 11th, 2021
- East vs. West: Battle of the rising stars! - ChessKid.com - chesskid.com - chesskid.com - June 11th, 2021
- New tables give you the opportunity to play chess/checkers at two EC parks - WQOW TV News 18 - May 30th, 2021
- A Chess Game: Everyone will win or lose after the NATO summit | Daily Sabah - Daily Sabah - May 30th, 2021
- Xiong Wins May 25 Titled Tuesday - Chess.com - May 30th, 2021
- Grandmaster Judit Polgar to Appear in US Chess Women Girls Club - uschess.org - May 30th, 2021
- Cummings, a chess man in a gambler's world | Comment | The Sunday Times - The Times - May 30th, 2021
- The inspiring journey behind 10-year-old chess masters success - Yahoo News - May 30th, 2021
- Chess event promotes solidarity between Jews and Arabs - The Jerusalem Post - May 30th, 2021
- Taylor Jenkins and Quin Snyder are in a NBA playoffs 'chess match' that's years in the making | Giannotto - Commercial Appeal - May 30th, 2021
- Mind games: Two intellectuals and chess on a football pitch - The Indian Express - May 30th, 2021
- Theatre review: Chess the Musical - InDaily - May 30th, 2021
- 10-Year-Old Chess Prodigy Who Overcame Homelessness Named National Chess Master - NewsOne - May 18th, 2021
- Top chess player in the world visits Indianapolis - WTHR - May 18th, 2021
- 10-year-old boy who once lived in a homeless shelter achieves remarkable title: chess master - USA TODAY - May 18th, 2021
- Ventura sweeps National Youth and Schools Online Chess Tourney - PhilBoxing.com - May 18th, 2021
- Chess master, former law enforcement officer to give seminar on surviving police interaction - - Champion - May 18th, 2021
- First Ever Chess-Focused Sports Agency Launched - World Chess - May 18th, 2021
- More than a game: How Cook County is using chess to prepare inmates for life on the outside - Daily Herald - May 18th, 2021
- The Queens Gambit Star Anya Taylor-Joy: Its Not About Chess, Its About Loneliness And The Price Of Genius Contenders TV - Deadline - May 18th, 2021
- Chess Market Is Expected To Expand At An Impressive Rate By 2027 KSU | The Sentinel Newspaper - KSU | The Sentinel Newspaper - May 18th, 2021
- Announcing The Botez Bullet Invitational On May 5 - Chess.com - May 5th, 2021
- New In Chess Classic: Carlsen Strikes - Chess.com - May 5th, 2021
- Jazz Cartier on His Chess Docuseries With Diddy, Skincare Line, and Next LP - Complex - May 5th, 2021
- Cover Stories with Chess Life #36: Taylor Kingston - uschess.org - May 5th, 2021
- Meet Tani Adewumi: The 10-year-old Nigerian refugee who became a national chess master | NewsChannel 3-12 - KEYT - May 5th, 2021
- Learn Chess Online With This Lesson Bundle, Which Is Currently 92% Off - Forbes - May 5th, 2021
- Are the Rams trying to play chess with NFL Draft pick Tutu Atwell? - With the First Pick - May 5th, 2021
- The Chess Match Ahead in the East - Japers' Rink - May 5th, 2021
- Mother tongue and chess is there a connection? - Chessbase News - May 5th, 2021
- Great Moments in Chess: Kasparov Seizes the Crown - chess24 - May 5th, 2021
- 'A sport for the mind': New chess team a big hit at MHS - Yahoo News - May 5th, 2021
- All India Chess Federation launches initiative to help chess community fight COVID-19 - Firstpost - May 5th, 2021
- It's your move: Pittsburgh police invite the public to play chess in Market Square - TribLIVE - April 21st, 2021
- Pittsburgh Police To Join Street Chess Players During The Summer - WTRF - April 21st, 2021
- Aagaard on the Candidates - Round 9 | US Chess.org - uschess.org - April 21st, 2021
- The game of Chess - The Times of India Blog - April 21st, 2021
- What America Taught The World About Chess - Chess.com - April 21st, 2021
- The real story of women in chess - The Independent - April 21st, 2021
- Cops in Paraguay discover 20k worth of high purity cocaine bound for Ireland inside chess set... - The Irish Sun - April 21st, 2021
- Mike Tyson heads to Arnold Schwarzeneggers mansion for game of chess and golf along with UFC icon Henry C... - The Sun - April 21st, 2021
- Classic games like chess and Sudoku are now easier to play on iPhones and iPads - TechRadar - April 5th, 2021
- Clash Mini: Everything we know about Supercell's upcoming auto chess game - Pocket Gamer - April 5th, 2021
- Bucs decision to bring back Godwin and Barrett was a chess game - Bucs Nation - April 5th, 2021
- Artemiev Swindles Nakamura To Win Another Titled Tuesday - Chess.com - March 9th, 2021
- Chess lovers practice the art of the checkmate - KNBN NewsCenter1 - Newscenter1.tv - March 9th, 2021
- Play Chess With Agadmator, Nemo, Cramling, Canty, And More - Chess.com - March 9th, 2021
- Turkish chess group head works to inspire young girls - Anadolu Agency - March 9th, 2021
- Chess Player Koneru Humpy Is The BBC Indian Sportswoman Of The Year - Femina - March 9th, 2021
- He loves the chess aspect: is Rooney made to measure as a manager? - The Guardian - March 9th, 2021
- Battle of the Minds: 4 legends compete in chess and poker - chess24 - March 9th, 2021
- Wednesday Workout: Leveling Up Through the US Chess Rapids - uschess.org - March 9th, 2021
- John Leguizamo on Critical Thinking [VIDEO] | US Chess.org - uschess.org - February 20th, 2021
- Teaching the right moves across the board - The Hindu - February 20th, 2021
- How this 25-year-old makes six figures a year playing chess on Twitch - CNBC - February 20th, 2021
- Maharashtra Chess Association back as a governing body after 4 years - The Bridge - February 20th, 2021
- Chess and Artificial Intelligence (1) - Chessbase News - February 17th, 2021
- Rockford Chess Club Gets Revived Thanks to ' The Queen's Gambit' - q985online.com - February 17th, 2021
- Aaron Chess, District 1 council candidate, wants to bring hope back to the district - CIProud.com - February 17th, 2021
- Check out these chess tips before you hear check mate - KELOLAND.com - February 17th, 2021
- Knight's Retreat Review - Chess but not! - TheXboxHub - February 17th, 2021
- Smashing Stereotypes - Marissa Saroca to play The Arbiter in CHESS THE MUSICAL | News - Aussie Theatre - February 17th, 2021
- Garry Kasparov at IMPROVATE Cybersecurity Conference is talking about Chess, IA and The Queen's Gambit - Yahoo Finance - February 17th, 2021
- Become a chess expert with these discounted grandmaster taught training bundles | TheHill - The Hill - February 15th, 2021
- When The Prison Banned Board Games, We Played Chess In Our Minds - The Marshall Project - February 15th, 2021
- Recruiting Chess Match: Huskies Have Missouri TE on Their Board - Sports Illustrated - February 15th, 2021
- xQc Is Going to Use His Expensive New PC to Play Chess and Browser Games - EssentiallySports - February 15th, 2021
- Our Collective Chess Match: What Our Editors Are Reading - Sojourners - February 15th, 2021
- Advanced chess with John Gallagher | Calendar | scarsdalenews.com - scarsdalenews.com - February 15th, 2021
- Across the MMA Universe: Kamaru Usman on UFC 258 'Chess Match' - Bleacher Report - February 15th, 2021
- More than 140 inmates will participate in virtual Chess Tournament - Dominican Today - February 15th, 2021
- Young Canadian chess stars lead drive to popularize the royal game on Twitch - Ottawa Citizen - February 15th, 2021