Microsoft recently announced that it had detected efforts by Russia, China, and Iran to influence the upcoming U.S. election. The discovery should not come as any surprise. In his 2019 testimony, former FBI Director Robert Mueller cautioned that Russias foreign election interference wasnt a single attempt. Theyre doing it as we sit here.
The reason the Russians attempted to influence the election outcome in 2016 is simple: They think that domestic politics matters for foreign policy. That calculus hasnt changed, so its no surprise that Russia is again interested in influencing the U.S. electoral outcome. Whats different this time around is the chess board of the international system: the actors, their preferred outcomes, and their preferred mechanisms of influence.
In the last election, although the Russians appeared to have a general preference for candidate Trump, they were primarily interested in sowing confusion, widening political divides, and exacerbating racial tensions. The benefit of a polarized U.S. domestic political landscape is straightforward: The more divided the United States is internally, the weaker it will be internationally and the less likely it will be to challenge and constrain Russian interests.
Coherent foreign policy is predicated on shared reference points, fundamental agreements across the aisle about U.S. international commitments. During the Cold War, the United States fashioned a bipartisan consensus that remained largely intact until the ball of the Berlin Wall and the break-up of the Soviet Union, perhaps with a blip during the post-Vietnam period. Containing Communism, in particular, generated overwhelming, consistent support that translated into a successful strategy. But the relative unity of purpose that marked American views toward the countrys role in the world has not persisted in the post-Soviet era.
Russian operatives seized on these divisions to carry out a remarkable campaign of political interference in the last election. That campaign consisted of two main prongs. First, operatives at the Russian Internet Research Agency (IRA) used the tools of digital personalizationfalse news articles, targeted ads, and user-generated contentto polarize Americans on the basis of societal, ideological, and racial differences and even to provoke real-world events, as the Senate Intelligence Committees 2019 report on that campaign documented. In the second prong, hackers affiliated with the Russian military intelligence agency, the GRU, broke into the computer systems of the Democratic National Committee and email accounts belonging to key political operatives, stole files and emails, and then leaked those documents online via WikiLeaks and other sites. These emails exposed and exacerbated internal divides in the Democratic Party, captivated the national media, and helped spur bizarre conspiracy theories that remain a potent force in American politics today.
As in the last election, Russian operatives again appear to be engaging in disinformation campaigns. Russian actors are again targeting Trumps opponent, spreading inaccuracies about former Vice President Joe Bidens mental health, continuing to stoke partisan acrimony online, and using Russian agents to push accusations of corruption about Biden, which led the Treasury Department to block assets belonging to several individuals involved in the smear campaign.
However, compared with 2016, a key difference in this election is that rather than relying on Russian native language speakers, whose grammatical errors in English have proven to be giveaways in the past, Russian operatives are instead co-opting Americans to write content for the 2020 campaign. Facebook and Twitter have both flagged news sites and accounts that look authentic but are actually tied to Russian political interference.
Isolated in the international system, stifling dissent at home, and sowing chaos abroad, Moscow has little to lose by using digital tools to keep the American electorate divided and helping to re-elect a president that poses perhaps the greatest threat to the democratic international order that Russia opposes. The goal is again to again exacerbate polarization, delegitimize the election and democracy in ways that will be an obvious impediment to coherent international leadership, and possibly boost Trump as the individual less likely to generate bipartisan accord.
Chinese operations for 2020
This time around, Russia is not the only key player in the digital disinformation game. The key addition for 2020 is China, which is now more of a player. But instead of favoring instability, Beijings goal is the opposite: stability. To be sure, Beijing has little interest in rendering the United States so weak that it destabilizes the global order altogether, but it would still like to see Washingtons relative power diminished. Consistent with that motive, the U.S. intelligence community reports that China prefers that President Trumpwhom Beijing sees as unpredictabledoes not win reelection.
Chinese intelligence gathering on American politics is not entirely new. In 2008, alleged Chinese government operators hacked into the campaigns of both presidential candidates Barack Obama and John McCain, presumably to gain insights about their policy positions. Its intelligence operations targeting political campaigns builds on a well-developed infrastructure for digital espionage that uses a combination of units within its intelligence apparatus and semi-independent contractors to target the computer systems of just about every major institution in American society.
But in targeting political campaigns, rather than overturning the diplomatic apple cart with aggressive hack-and-leak campaigns like the Russians, the Chinese approach is a combination of information gathering and agenda promotion. Four years into Trumps presidency, the Chinese government is well versed in his policy positions and political style. Its insights on a potential Biden administration, however, are less well developed. In June, Google reported that it has detected attempts by Chinese hackers to break into email accounts of Biden staffers, in what is likely to be an attempt to gain insight on his campaign rather than the early stages of a hack-and-leak operation.
Beyond trying to collect intelligence by hacking into the Biden campaign, China is exploiting higher social media usage during the pandemic to promote its preferred narratives. As part of Beijings effort to offer an attractive alternative to U.S. global leadership, official Chinese government tweets question U.S. progress in responding to COVID-19, deride race relations in the United States, and counter U.S. official messaging regarding human rights in Xinjiang.
In its campaign of propaganda and misinformation, China has scored some viral hits, including a notable dig at the United Statess handling of COVID-19. That cartoon video contrasts Chinas treatment of the pandemic with the United Statess by putting a Lego version of a Chinese terracotta warrior in conversation with a Lego Statue of Liberty. The terracotta warrior makes the case for Chinas effective handling of the virus, while the Statue of Liberty accuses it of lying and obfuscating the risk posed by the coronavirus. The video is a modern day inverse of an American propaganda video from 1949, Meet King Joe, that promotes the life of the American worker over that of the Chinese worker. In 1949, American propaganda was promoting U.S. corporate efficiency and its benefit to workers; in 2020, Chinese propaganda is highlighting its superior handling of COVID-19.
The Iranian response to maximum pressure
Irans anti-Trump administration tack stems from the antipathy toward the maximum pressure approach of the incumbent. As a candidate, Trump signaled his disdain toward the Iran nuclear agreement, and in May 2018 announced U.S. withdrawal from the agreement in May 2018. The Trump administration initiated new sanctions starting in 2017 and has continued to tighten the economic screws throughout. Biden, by contrast, has signaled his support for the nuclear agreement, which provides for sanctions relief in exchange for limits on Irans nuclear program. Given a choice between conflict or cooperation, it is not surprising that Iran would lean into a Biden administration that might reinstate the status quo ante.
Consistent with these preferences, Iran has sought to hack into accounts of Trump campaign staff. The Iran-backed group, known as Charming Kitten and Phosphorus, has been associated with phishing attacks, in which the email appears to come from an antivirus email but is actually laced with malware. Official US sources have cited Iranian efforts at spreading disinformation on social media and recirculating anti-US content, although few specifics have been given.
Foreign election interference is nothing new. Countries have long recognized both that leadership matters, and that the inability to lead because of domestic division can redound to their benefit.
Yet what is new are the digital tools states now have at their disposal to interfere in foreign elections. Wielded well, these tools can generate massive payoffs for very little cost. After the success of its efforts in 2016, for example, Russia more than doubled its IRA budget in 2018to $35 million. The increase prompted Congress to appropriate $425 million for states to upgrade their voting systems, a tit-for-tat that has forced the United States to spend exorbitant amounts on defensive measures simply to break even on democratic legitimacy.
The question now is whether those moves will be enough. With Russia, China, and Iran all seeking greater influence online, the dynamic somewhat resembles a Cold War arms race, but with information rather than missiles as the weapon. Whether the United States has learned how to guard against those weapons, and their evolving use, remains far from clear.
Sarah Kreps is a nonresident senior fellow in the Foreign Policy program at Brookings, a professor of government, and the Milstein Faculty Fellow in Technology and Humanity at Cornell University.
Facebook, Google, Microsoft, and Twitter provide financial support to the Brookings Institution, a nonprofit organization devoted to rigorous, independent, in-depth public policy research.
See more here:
- Canadian chess master Ross Siemms pleased with new interest in the game - Toronto Sun - January 13th, 2021
- CES 2021: check out the world's craziest new gaming and consumer tech - Happy Mag - January 13th, 2021
- A Black Repertoire versus the Anti-Sicilians - Chessbase News - January 13th, 2021
- 'The Last of Us' prologue easter egg discovered after seven years - NME - January 13th, 2021
- Trolling the Great Outdoors - The New Yorker - January 13th, 2021
- Good, bad, and ugly 2020 - The New Indian Express - December 29th, 2020
- DeepMind's New AI Is Able To Learn The Rules Of A Game As It Plays - Unite.AI - December 27th, 2020
- Chess captures new fans thanks to the pandemic and 'The Queen's Gambit' - CBC.ca - December 27th, 2020
- Bridgewater Man And Woman Arrested In Connection To Stabbing On Christmas Eve - Yahoo News - December 27th, 2020
- Off Their Game Week 16 - Robby Anderson - Yahoo News - December 27th, 2020
- Five Tips To Become A World Chess Champion: Vasily Smyslov's Story - Chess.com - December 27th, 2020
- 20 top TV moments of 2020: From 'Jeopardy!' to 'Tiger King' and that wild election - USA TODAY - December 26th, 2020
- The Westbridge Anand Chess Academy will train five of India's biggest talents - Chessbase News - December 23rd, 2020
- Chess sets are in-demand on LI right now - Newsday - December 23rd, 2020
- Elliot Page Was Supposed to Star in The Queens Gambit - Rare.us - December 22nd, 2020
- Are computers killing the mystery of chess? video - The Guardian - December 20th, 2020
- From Bake Off woes to Zoom fiascos: 2020 in lists - The Guardian - December 20th, 2020
- KCF University Cup to be played online in February - Chessbase News - December 20th, 2020
- 2020 smartphone mega shootout: The best camera phones tested - Android Authority - December 20th, 2020
- The best websites to play chess after watching 'Queen's Gambit' | Tech | December 17, 2020 - Explica - December 17th, 2020
- Barbara Kay: The glaring flaw of 'The Queens Gambit' that no one wants to mention - National Post - December 12th, 2020
- Best of 2020: How The Queen's Gambit made its chess look real - Entertainment Weekly - December 11th, 2020
- 5 Easy Steps That You Need to Follow To Become A Micro Influencer - Vizaca.com - December 11th, 2020
- Omena, Miguna and onions most googled in 2020 - The Standard - December 11th, 2020
- Pegasystems' Trefler on leadership and strategy - learned from chess - Financial Post - December 8th, 2020
- Inuit-designed board game Nunami hits the shelves - Nunatsiaq News - December 8th, 2020
- How to play chess like Beth from The Queen's Gambit - The Spectator US - December 5th, 2020
- INTERVIEW: Video creation app Firework insists it is more than a TikTok rival as it woos publishers in India - Business Insider India - December 3rd, 2020
- Meghan and Harry are in hot water over The Crown and their Netflix deal - NEWS.com.au - December 3rd, 2020
- The Cord's Best of 2020 The Cord - The Cord - December 3rd, 2020
- Madonna Shared a Rare, Festive Family Portrait Ahead of the Holidays - HarpersBAZAAR.com - December 1st, 2020
- 'The Queen's Gambit' got you feeling chess? The best websites to play on - Film Daily - December 1st, 2020
- Mr Beast teases chess match with grandmaster Hikaru - Dexerto - December 1st, 2020
- The 42 Best Black Friday Smart Home and Kitchen Deals (2020) - WIRED - November 29th, 2020
- Black Friday 2020 Live Update: A later Black Friday boost; hot holiday gifts: Legos and chess sets - CNBC - November 27th, 2020
- Chess championship: A 10-year-old Filipino takes over global stage - Yahoo News - November 27th, 2020
- Netflix, HBO Max Battle Over 'Godzilla' Rights, Disney Plus Performs 'On Pointe' - The Streamable - November 27th, 2020
- A game-changing moment for chess - CNN Video - November 26th, 2020
- Carlsen on The Queen's Gambit: A little too unrealistic - Chessbase News - November 26th, 2020
- Understanding before Moving 2: How to improve the activity of my pieces - Chessbase News - November 24th, 2020
- Gurgaon girl to represent India in World Youth Chess Championship - Times of India - November 24th, 2020
- ChessBase 16 - The new features (Part 5) - Chessbase News - November 20th, 2020
- The Queen's Gambit: How a Netflix show is increasing the popularity of chess - CNN - November 20th, 2020
- Cybercrimes can cost companies money, customers, and employees. Here's what types of cybersecurity protocols e - Business Insider India - November 18th, 2020
- Politicians are conquering the world of video games - Metro US - November 18th, 2020
- ChessBase 16 - The new features (Part 4) - Chessbase News - November 16th, 2020
- How "The Queen's Gambit" is inspiring a wave of new chess fans, especially women - Salon - November 16th, 2020
- 5 great shows to watch on Netflix this weekend - Netflix Life - November 8th, 2020
- Chess and scientific research - Chessbase News - November 6th, 2020
- Harry Melling on 'Queen's Gambit' and His Haunting Liam Neeson Team-Up - Hollywood Reporter - November 5th, 2020
- Darrell Hammond on Sean Connery Impression: "The Single Most Successful Thing I Ever Did As a Performer" - Hollywood Reporter - November 5th, 2020
- Win or lose, with Trump, prepare for the unimaginable after the election - CNN - November 1st, 2020
- VIDEOS - Play Chess with Friends - October 31st, 2020
- Play Chess Online - Free Online Chess on GameKnot - October 31st, 2020
- Chess videos | chess24.com - October 31st, 2020
- Gillian Jacobs Talks Improvising for the First Time on Dont Think Twice - Yahoo Lifestyle - October 31st, 2020
- TikToker Abby Roberts reacts to bizarre theory shes not really British - Dexerto - October 31st, 2020
- New Movies + Shows to Watch this Weekend: 'Borat 2' on Amazon Prime Video+ More - Decider - October 24th, 2020
- Premiere: Sweet Crude Reaches Their "Ultimatum" - Popdust - October 23rd, 2020
- Gordon Ramsay Sipped Ocean Spray In His Latest TikTok Tirade, Referencing The Viral 'Dreams' Video - Delish.com - October 23rd, 2020
- 'Roger Federer is always out-thinking you and ready to embarrass you," says former US Open opponent - Tennishead - October 21st, 2020
- 'The Queen's Gambit' Cast on How the Netflix Drama Goes Beyond the Chess Board (VIDEO) - TV Insider - October 17th, 2020
- Norway Chess: Carlsen clinches with a round to spare - Chessbase News - October 16th, 2020
- Norway Chess: Carlsen beats Caruana to take the lead - Chessbase News - October 11th, 2020
- Connected pawns on the move - Chessbase News - October 11th, 2020
- New: Sergei Tiviakov - How to play the Ruy Lopez with Qe2 - Chessbase News - October 7th, 2020
- AdvanceClub Launches to Inspire and Advance Esports Gamers of All Skill Levels - StreetInsider.com - October 7th, 2020
- Woman Can't Stump Her Husband With Riddles No Matter How Hard She Tries - Distractify - October 3rd, 2020
- Unearthing Every NFL Team's Early Hidden Gem - Bleacher Report - September 30th, 2020
- The Queens Gambit Teaser: Anya Taylor-Joy Is Addicted to Chess, Drugs, and More Chess - Vulture - September 28th, 2020
- 'Console Wars' Review: A Fascinating, Fundamental Chronicle of the Innovative Battle Between SEGA and Nintendo - /FILM - September 24th, 2020
- WATCH: Why Nurse-Stevens was the best chess match in NBA history - Celtics Wire - September 24th, 2020
- Yuzvendra Chahals Dance Videos That Went Viral! - IWMBuzz - September 22nd, 2020
- The 7 best chess and checkers games for Android - Explica - September 12th, 2020
- FIDE announces that the Candidates Tournament will resume on November 1st - Chessbase News - September 11th, 2020
- George Conway Shows What's Going On In Trump's Head In Exclusive 'Unfit' Clip - HuffPost - September 11th, 2020
- Pokelawls signed as streamer to TSM - Daily Esports - September 9th, 2020
- 30 fun ways to stay connected through video calls - Bryan-College Station Eagle - September 7th, 2020
- TikTok: Everything To Know About Tech's Biggest Soap Opera - Inventiva - September 5th, 2020
- Putin critic: Inaction against him is a license to kill - CNN - September 5th, 2020